Breaking
HOA Diligence

Updated Performance Measurement Module Enhances Real Estate Reporting Standards

By Cole Ashford 4 min read
A business analyst reviews a colorful bar chart and documents at a desk, indicating data analysis.
A business analyst reviews a colorful bar chart and documents at a desk, indicating data analysis. Photo: RDNE Stock project/Pexels

The Performance Measurement module has been updated to clarify the description of assumptions and enable more detailed performance analysis. It now includes a methodology for asset-level return calculation, aligning with the INREV Asset Level Index. Additionally, new guidelines for calculating gross of fee performance returns have been introduced to assess the impact and complexity of fee models. These updates aim to provide investment managers with clearer support when computing and reporting historic performance measures, both at the vehicle and asset levels.

The module is effective for reporting periods ending on or after December 31, 2022, ensuring a standardized approach to performance measurement in the European non-listed real estate industry.

Standardizing Performance Reporting

The module is designed primarily for direct property vehicles and aims to increase consistency in performance reporting to investors. This standardization will also improve the relevance of indices like the INREV Indices, which can serve as points of reference for comparing vehicle and asset performance. By providing a common framework, the module facilitates more meaningful comparisons across different vehicles and assets, particularly those with similar investment mandates, objectives, or strategies.

By aligning with frameworks like the Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS) and the NCREIF PREA Reporting Standards, the module seeks to avoid conflicts in methodologies while adapting to the European non-listed real estate industry’s practices. This alignment ensures that performance measures are both globally recognized and locally relevant, supporting trust among investors.

Compliance and Disclosure Requirements

Investment managers are required to evaluate their compliance with the guidelines through periodic self-assessments. The level of compliance and an annual score representing compliance effectiveness must be disclosed to investors in the annual report. This process is facilitated by INREV’s self-assessment tool, as detailed in the Adoption and Compliance Framework of the INREV Guidelines.

Performance measures and disclosure levels may vary depending on the vehicle’s style, type, structure, and strategy. For instance, money-weighted returns are more relevant for closed-end vehicles, while time-weighted returns are more appropriate for open-end vehicles. This flexibility ensures that performance metrics are tailored to the specific characteristics of each vehicle, enhancing their accuracy and usefulness.

The module introduces several new metrics, including specific calculations for vehicle-level performance measures like time-weighted returns (TWR) and total vehicle-level returns on both a gross and net of fees basis. These metrics are designed to provide a full view of performance, accounting for various factors that influence returns.

Investment managers must disclose the computed performance measures, methodologies, and any significant assumptions used. The use of the INREV NAV is encouraged, and any adjustments to the vehicle NAV should be properly disclosed. This transparency ensures that investors have a clear understanding of how performance measures are calculated and what assumptions underpin them.

Performance measures should be calculated at the same frequency as the published NAV valuation, with an annual minimum. Investments held by a vehicle are expected to be measured at fair value, regardless of the GAAP used to determine the NAV. This consistency in valuation frequency and methodology enhances the reliability and comparability of performance data.

For periods without property valuations, an NAV can still be determined to provide a data point. Asset-level performance measures should be calculated at the same frequency as property valuations and on a currency-neutral basis. This approach ensures that performance measures remain relevant and informative even when property valuations are not available.

Asset-Level Performance and Currency Considerations

These calculations must be currency-neutral, ensuring a standardized comparison across assets. This currency-neutral approach eliminates the distortion caused by exchange rate fluctuations, providing a clearer picture of underlying performance.

Income Return and Net Investment Income

The module mandates the disclosure of a vehicle-level income return. This return reflects the net operational income, calculated on an accrual basis. It includes rental and other income from direct and indirect investments, minus associated costs. Net investment income provides a focused view of operational performance, excluding capital transactions and valuation changes that can obscure underlying trends.

Net investment income excludes capital transactions, valuation gains or losses, transaction costs, and taxes on capital profits and losses. It provides a clear picture of the vehicle’s operating performance, separate from capital movements. This distinction is key for investors seeking to understand the recurring income-generating capacity of the vehicle.

A total vehicle level return on a time-weighted basis should be disclosed in the annual report, covering one, three, five, and ten-year periods (where applicable) and since inception, on an annualized basis. Annualization calculations account for the exact number of days when returns are for periods longer than one year. This detailed breakdown allows investors to assess performance over various time horizons, providing a more subtle understanding of the vehicle’s historical returns.

Cole Ashford

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *